DMV Hearing Defense
Home Up

 

 

GUSTAFSON LAW OFFICE
COLORADO DRIVER'S LICENSE DEFENSE - COLORADO DMV / DOR HEARINGS
COLORADO DRIVER LICENSE SUSPENSION, REVOCATION OR DENIAL DEFENSE

WELCOME Phone (719) 260-1002 Fax (719) 260-1003 

perhaps I will become your attorney
Address  *  Maps  *  Directions
 

Robert D. Gustafson  *  Attorney at Law  *  Colorado Springs
Business Hours  *  Attorney Availability  *  Trade Area
 
Toll Free (800) 410-1002
 
 
PRIVATE ATTORNEY
NOT
THE DMV

I welcome representation inquiries
but please do not call thinking this office is the Colorado DMV

COLORADO DRIVER LICENSE DEFENSE
WEBPAGE INDEX - NAVIGATIONAL LINKS
COLORADO DMV HEARING DEFENSE  *  SUSPENSION  *  REVOCATION  *  DENIAL
COLORADO SPRINGS DRIVER LICENSE DEFENSE ATTORNEY
Colorado driver's license suspension, revocation or denial defense - Colorado Department of Revenue - DOR
Colorado Division of Motor Vehicles, Colorado DMV, Colorado MVD

Trial practice 25+ years Colorado state courts, Colorado Springs Municipal Court & Colorado DMV license hearings
SUSPENSION, REVOCATION OR DENIAL
GENERAL INFORMATION & HEARING PROCEDURE
ADVERSE ACTION - ALCOHOL RELATED
2008 Pending DUI License & Interlock Legislation  HB 08-1194
All Drivers - BAC Refusal Revocation
Refusal - Chemical Testing
Excessive Alcohol Adult Driver Revocation
BAC .08 - .169  BAC .17 or Greater
Alcohol Excessive BAC Plus
Point Suspension
Alcohol Chemical Test Refusal Plus
Point Suspension
Alcohol Related Convictions
Habitual Offender
Excessive Alcohol * Refusal
Alcohol Conviction * Out of Service

Commercial Driver License - CDL
Alcohol Driving Offenses
Alcohol Convictions within 5 Years
Alcohol Driving Offenses
Alcohol Convictions Within Lifetime
Alcohol Conviction - "Baby DUI"
Minor Driver or Provisional Driver
Underage Excessive Alcohol "Baby DEAC"
Underage Driver Revocation
Alcohol Conviction - Underage DUI
Minor Driver or Provisional Driver
Alcohol Conviction - Underage MIP
Minor - Possession - Consumption
ADVERSE ACTION - NON-ALCOHOL
Excessive Points Suspension
non-alcohol
Potential Defenses
non-alcohol
OJW Suspension
outstanding judgment warrant
Habitual Offender Revocation
non-alcohol
POTENTIAL DEFENSES
Penalty Assessment Traffic Infractions
SUSPENSION, REVOCATION OR DENIAL - DURATION
   
Base Periods of Point Suspension
   
Base Periods
Other Suspension Revocation or Denial
ATTORNEY POLICIES
Attorney Representation & Declined Matters
Legal Advice to Clients - Not General Public
Pro Bono Representation or Installment Payment
Representation Now - Another Attorney or Self
Post Hearing - Appeal to District Court or Court of Appeals
Cases Outside Colorado Springs - Travel
   

TRAFFIC DEFENSE

DUI - DWAI - DEAC  *  Driving Under Restraint  *  No Operator's License  *  Speeding DMV DEFENSE DMV Appeal
Speed Contest - Drag Racing  *  Eluding Police  *  Hit & Run  *  Compulsory Insurance License Hearings * Point Structure * Forms
Reckless Driving - Careless Driving  *    *  Weaving - Roadways Laned for Traffic Habitual Offender  *  Interstate Compact
Minor - Alcohol Red Light - Stop Sign  *  Traffic Definitions  *  Traffic Infraction vs. Crime  *  Traffic Cameras Insurance SR-22 Interlock  Driving Records
 
they who most wrongfully intend to snatch my driver's license Colorado Department of Revenue
Colorado Dept. of Revenue Colorado Division of Motor Vehicles
Colorado Dept. of Motor Vehicles Colorado DMV
Colorado DOR Colorado MVD
 Adobe Acrobat Reader version 5 or later is required to view .pdf files    Free Download

 

DRIVING PRIVILEGES
SUSPENSION  *  REVOCATION  *  DENIAL
GENERAL INFORMATION & HEARING PROCEDURE

 

Loss of Colorado driving privileges, probationary license, interlock and reinstatement are complex issues with multiple variables.  A substantial amount of information is contained within this webpage for educational purpose only.  Information is contained relative to common license actions, but it is not possible to address all possible permutations.  Do not rely upon information contained herein - contact Colorado DMV Driver Control License Reinstatement Section to determine status of Colorado driving privileges, probationary license eligibility, interlock eligibility & reinstatement requirements.

 *    *    *    *    *    *

Attorney welcomes representation inquiries however before calling please refer to first consultation - the purpose is not to provide free legal advice to the general public.  Unless seeking to retain counsel, please do not email or call.  Attorney does not provide legal opinions, answers or information in response to questions submitted from non-clients.  Given the scope of internet accessibility I can not be the free "Colorado answer man" and will politely decline.

 

        Driving PrivilegeIn Colorado, driving is a privilege, not a right, and most of us take our driving privileges for granted.  Places are much further away than we realize when we have access to a vehicle.  Driver's license or Colorado driving privileges may be taken for one or more of the below identified reasons. This list is not intended to be exhaustive - just highlight the most common reasons.  

 

        DOR Overview.  The Department of Revenue is an administrative agency created by statute.  It has no more or less power than granted by the legislature.  Many functions are mandatory pursuant to statute; the DOR has discretion only when granted by statute.  The DOR has also promulgated rules and regulations; some are linked in this website.

 

        DOR Hearing Structure Hearings regarding Colorado license or Colorado driving privileges loss occur in DOR district offices across the state.  The hearing officer is actually employed not by the DMV, but by the Colorado Department of Revenue, Hearing and Appeals Division.  This is a branch of the Colorado Department of Revenue which is separate and distinct from the DMV.  Drivers commonly believe the Colorado license or Colorado driving privileges has been suspended, revoked or denied by the DMV, so that is the phraseology which is used in this webpage and the DMV Appeals webpage.

 

        Statutory Basis - License Loss.  The respondent's driver license or Colorado driving privileges are in jeopardy on the basis of a particular statute. e.g.
                a.) CRS 42-2-127 points
                b.) CRS 42-2-126 excessive alcohol or refusing a chemical test
                c.) CRS 42-2-125 multiple alcohol offense convictions, MIP, baby DUI
                d.)
CRS 42-2-201 et. seq. - habitual offender
                e.) CRS 42-2-127.7 compulsory insurance
        If the criteria of the particular underlying statute are are met, the driver license will be suspended, revoked or denied.

 

        Rules Governing Hearing.  DMV hearings are conducted pursuant to CRS 24-4-105, the Colorado Administrative Procedures Act (APA).  In some circumstances, conduct or rules of the hearing are are provided in a specific statute.  e.g. refusing a chemical test or excessive alcohol content revocation CRS 42-2-126.  DOR regulations also apply regarding conduct of hearings.  Under the relaxed rules of the APA, hearsay is admissible, including multiple levels of hearsay.  This is unfavorable to the respondent driver.

 

        Setting Hearings.  In hearings such as excessive alchohol or refusing a chemical test, the adverse action is effective immediately upon service of notice, with the right to request a hearing within 7 days from service of the notice of adverse action.  In such circumstances, the respondent driver may request the presence of the arresting officer at hearing.  In other circumstances such as points, notice is sent to the driver.  Hearing date has been scheduled and is identified in the notice.  In yet other circumstances such as driving under restraint, notice of adverse action is sent to the driver.  DMV has already taken the adverse action which is mandated by Colorado law CRS 42-2-138, and the driver is simply notified of the action.  DUR = 1 additional year loss to run consecutively with any other adverse action.  In such circumstance, a hearing may also be requested upon receipt of notice.

 

        Subpoena.  In criminal & traffic court cases, attorneys may issue a subpoena or subpoena duces tecum (document production) and no particular form is required.  In DOR hearing actions, statutes and DOR regulations require that a subpoena or subpoena duces tecum may only be issued by the DOR hearing officer & that it must be upon a DOR form.

Only Denver DOR Hearings & Appeals may issue a subpoena, not a local DOR hearing officer. 

Under law applicable to excessive alcohol or refusing a chemical test, hearings, the DOR is only required to give 10 days advance notice of hearing and a subpoena must be served upon a law enforcement officer no later than 5 calendar days in advance of hearing.  CRS 42-2-126(8)(e)(I),(II) 

If at the time of hearing request the driver fails to request the presence of the law enforcement officer, it can be quite difficult to get a subpoena issued and served under this rule. 

If the law enforcement officer under subpoena is unable to attend, he or she may notify the DOR & a continuance will be granted, which may be outside the 60 day statute of limitations.  If a driver or his/her attorney is unable to attend, he or she may notify the DOR, however a continuance will only be granted upon good cause shown and the new hearing date must be within the 60 day statute of limitations.  If the hearing date is near the limitation period - no extension will be granted to the driver for any reason. 

In a criminal case, the state has some advantages and defense has some advantages.  The two sides are essentially balanced walking into hearing or trial.  The above are a few of the reasons publishing attorney believes DOR hearings are fundamentally unfair in favor of the state - the deck is stacked against the respondent driver in license hearings.

 

        Conduct of Hearing.  Hearings are generally conducted in a regular looking office with the DOR hearing officer seated behind the desk.  The Law enforcement officer frequently sits beside the desk with the respondent driver & counsel or witness seated opposite the hearing officer in front of the desk.  The hearing is recorded.  The recorder continues even if the hearing officer leaves the room, so care must be taken to avoid candid remarks or statements as no privacy exists.  The hearing officer will identify himself and have each person in the room identify himself or herself for the record.  The hearing officer will identify the allegations - reason for the hearing.  Witnesses, if any, are sworn and the hearing officer proceeds to take testimony and accept exhibits from a law enforcement officer if one is present.  Respondent driver is afforded an opportunity to cross examine the law enforcement officer, and to subsequently offer his or her own witnesses, self testimony or exhibits.  At conclusion of testimony, an opportunity is afforded for closing statement and the hearing officer then enters a ruling.

        Burden of Proof.  The burden of proof is upon the state by a preponderance of the evidence.  CRS 42-2-126, Schocke v. Colorado Department of Revenue, 719 P.2d 361 (Colo.App. 1986).

If ruling is in favor of the driver, the license is returned and the case concluded. 

If ruling is in favor of the state, the license or any temporary permit is seized and the hearing provides a copy of the suspension, revocation or denial order to the driver.  The hearing officer may advise the driver regarding potential penalties for driving under restraint, but is not required to do so.

The hearing officer will typically present the original order to the driver and request the driver to sign the order acknowledging receipt.  When present, publishing attorney makes a statement on the record that he acknowledges receipt on behalf of the client, but advises the client not to execute the DOR order.  No sense giving the DOR evidence for subsequent use in a driving under restraint prosecution.  Hearing officers do not get excited when a driver states: "I respectfully decline execution based upon advice of counsel."  Don't sign the DOR order.

 

        Right to Appeal.  If the Colorado driver license or Colorado driving privileges are suspended, revoked or denied, please refer to the DMV Appeals webpage for appellate information.
        Limited time exists to appeal.

 

        Penalties and Procedure Plea bargaining is not available - at the DMV hearing a driver wins or loses.

In many circumstances, the period of suspension, revocation or denial is statutory and the hearing officer has no discretion.  Several statutory periods are stated below; no shorter and no longer.  Regarding point suspension, hearing officer discretion exists as to length of driving privilege loss.

The DMV may have the statutory power to grant a probationary license.   If the DOR has that power, whether the limited driving privileges are granted or not is within the discretion of the hearing officer.  If statutory authority does not exist, no discretion exists for the DOR hearing officer.

For alcohol offenses, insurance offense and some other circumstances, to become reinstated the driver must file SR-22 proof of insurance. This is expensive high risk insurance, check with an independent insurance agent regarding cost.

DMV revocation for excessive alcohol content or refusing a chemical test is independent of any underlying alcohol criminal charges; even if the alcohol criminal case is dismissed, it will not affect a DMV license revocation order. 

Other DMV adverse actions are dependent upon valid conviction before the DMV may suspend, revoke or deny.

Where adverse actions are based upon prior convictions, relevant periods are computed from date of offense to date of offense - conviction dates are not relevant.

 

        Application for Driver License in Another StateIf driving privileges are under suspension, revocation or denial at the time a driver makes application for a new license in another state, the driver will not be issued a license out of state until the Colorado hold is cleared.  If application is made in Colorado during a period of suspension, revocation or denial, the driver be charged with a separate jailable major traffic offense simply for making the application.  Refer to National Records and False Information - Interstate Compact page

RELEVANT STATUTES

SUSPENSION  *  REVOCATION  *  DENIAL  *  PROBATIONARY LICENSE  *  INTERLOCK  *  LIMITED TRAFFIC CHARGES
refer to link for verbatim statutes - statutes may have been amended since published herein

ALCOHOL RELATED DMV ADVERSE ACTIONS

2008 Pending DUI License & Interlock Legislation  House Bill 08-1194

 

REFUSAL TO SUBMIT TO BLOOD OR BREATH TESTING

REVOCATION OR DENIAL - ADULT DRIVER'S LICENSE

ALCOHOL RELATED DMV ADVERSE ACTIONS
CRS 42-2-126(2)(a)(II)  BAC Refusal Revocation or Denial
Relevant Statutes

BASIC INFORMATION

ELEMENTS PERIOD OF LOSS
PROBATIONARY LICENSE
First Offense or Revocation
PROBATIONARY LICENSE
Second or Subsequent Offense or Revocation
REINSTATEMENT
First Offense or Revocation
REINSTATEMENT
Second or Subsequent Offense or Revocation

 

        General Information - BAC Refusal:  Chemical testing refusal - no 2 hour time limit - refusal may have occurred outside the excessive alcohol 2 hour time limit
        If a driver refuses to submit to breath or blood chemical testing, the driver should receive a notice of revocation or denial at the time of arrest or receipt of the summons and complaint(s) - tickets. This is usually on a yellow piece of paper; size 8 1/2" x 11". From date of receipt, the driver has
7 days to ask for a hearing. If the driver asks within that time, the driver will receive a hearing to determine whether driving privileges should be revoked or denied. If the driver fails to ask within 7 days, the driver has waived (forfeited - given up) the right to such a hearing, and driving privileges automatically will be revoked or denied for the period indicated below.
CRS 42-2-126. When the driver requests a hearing, he / she should demand that the officer be ordered to appear. Otherwise, the determination will be on the basis of written reports submitted by the officer.

        Basic Elements which Must be Proven to Revoke - BAC Refusal     note - other defenses may exist
        1.  The person identified as Respondent was the driver of a motor vehicle within the State of Colorado and within the jurisdiction of the law enforcement officer
        2.  The law enforcement officer had reasonable suspicion to stop or otherwise come in contact with the driver
        3.  The law enforcement officer had probable cause to believe the driver drove a motor vehicle while he or she was under the influence of or impaired alcohol or drug
                        this is tantamount to: the law enforcement officer had probable cause to to invoke Colorado express consent law
        4.  The law enforcement officer had probable cause to and did request a chemical test of the driver's blood or breath pursuant to Colorado express consent law
        5.  The driver refused to submit to a chemical test of his blood or breath.  Refusal may be by oral statement, behavior or physical manifestation.
        6.  Colorado DMV Appeal - information regarding appeal from DMV license revocation

Relevant Information - BAC Refusal

a. Period of Driving Privilege Loss - BAC Refusal
  First refusal revocation: 1 year CRS 42-2-126(6)(b)(III)  
  Second refusal revocation: 2 years CRS 42-2-126(6)(b)(IV)  
  Third or subsequent refusal revocation: 3 years CRS 42-2-126(6)(b)(VII)  
b. Probationary License - BAC Refusal Revocation - interim restricted license during restraint
    red license to drive back and forth to work or on the job or other locations or activities approved by DMV - limited purpose license

Probationary License - First Revocation - BAC Refusal

Eligibility.  not eligible during the first year; thereafter eligible

Authority.  CRS 42-2-132(2)(a)(I), CRS 42-2-126(7)(a) and no statutory provision granting DOR discretion except CRS 42-2-132.5(1.5)(a) "A person whose privilege to drive has been revoked for more than one year because of a violation of any provision of CRS 42-4-1301 §§ (1)(a), (1b) or (2) or has been revoked for more than one year under any provision of CRS 42-2-126 may voluntarily apply for an early reinstatement with a restricted license under the provisions of this section after the person's privilege to drive has been revoked for one year. The restrictions imposed pursuant to this section shall remain in effect for the longer of one year or the total time period remaining on the license restraint prior to early reinstatement."

Written & Driving Test Requirement:

Yes

refer to reinstatement testing information below

Interlock Requirement:     

None

refer to reinstatement interlock information below (other adverse action may impose interlock)

Insurance Requirement:   

 

refer to reinstatement insurance information below

Type of Insurance.  Mandatory SR-22 Insurance 

Period Required.  duration of probationary license

Authority.  CRS 42-2-132.5(1.5)(b(II)

Educational Requirement: Yes refer to reinstatement educational information below

Attorney Recommendation to Clients: If point suspension or other adverse action is imposed following the first year non eligibility for probationary license, the risk thereafter likely justifies application  Nevertheless, refer to Probationary License and Interlock Warning.

Termination of Probationary License interim license loss  **  final termination  **  issuance limitations - once per 5 years

 

Probationary License - Second or Subsequent Revocation - BAC Refusal

Eligibility.  not eligible during the first year; thereafter eligible

Authority.  CRS 42-2-132(2)(a)(I), CRS 42-2-126(7)(a) and no statutory provision granting DOR discretion except CRS 42-2-132.5(1.5)(a) "A person whose privilege to drive has been revoked for more than one year because of a violation of any provision of CRS 42-4-1301 §§ (1)(a), (1b) or (2) or has been revoked for more than one year under any provision of CRS 42-2-126 may voluntarily apply for an early reinstatement with a restricted license under the provisions of this section after the person's privilege to drive has been revoked for one year.  The restrictions imposed pursuant to this section shall remain in effect for the longer of one year or the total time period remaining on the license restraint prior to early reinstatement."

Written & Driving Test Requirement:

Yes

refer to reinstatement testing information below

Interlock Requirement:     

Yes

refer to reinstatement interlock information below & to persistent drunk driver  (consecutive)

Insurance Requirement:   

 

refer to reinstatement insurance information below

Type of Insurance.  Mandatory SR-22 Insurance 

Period Required.  duration of probationary license

Authority.  CRS 42-2-132.5(1.5)(b(II)

Educational Requirement: Yes refer to reinstatement educational information below

Attorney Recommendation to Clients: Where BAC .017 or greater, multiple offense convictions or multiple alcohol related revocations bring persistent drunk driver (PDD) into play, the driver will be required to maintain a interlock for two (2) years following reinstatement under a restricted probationary license, so if eligible, early reinstatement is not really increasing the driver's risk of early reinstatement probationary license suspension or cancellation.  Put another way, if PDD is applicable, early reinstatement risk is the least of your worries - request interlock early reinstatement when eligible.  Nevertheless, refer to Probationary License and Interlock Warning.

Termination of Probationary License interim license loss  **  final termination  **  issuance limitations - once per 5 years
c. Reinstatement Information - BAC Refusal:
  Reinstatement - First Revocation - BAC Refusal   refer to link Continuing License Loss Until Reinstatement  
1.  Application for reinstatement: by mail only to DMV Driver Control Section - Reinstatement  - not allowed at any DMV Office    
2.  Written and driving tests:  mandatory.  CRS 42-2-126(7)(c)(I), CRS 42-2-111, DOR Regulation 1 CCR 204-6
3.  Mandatory interlock restricted license:  no requirement
4.  Insurance Requirement - BAC Refusal - First Revocation

Insurance - BAC Refusal - First Revocation - First Revocation - No Accident

Type of Insurance. 

Mandatory SR-22 Insurance 

Period Required. 

1 year or period of license restriction  
Authority.  CRS 42-7-408(1)(c)(I)

Insurance - BAC Refusal - First Revocation - First Revocation - Accident Involved

Type of Insurance.

Mandatory SR-22 Insurance 

Period Required. 

3 years or period of license restriction (longer period)
Authority.  CRS 42-7-408(1)(b)
5.  Education required for reinstatement   CRS 42-2-126(7)(c), CRS 42-2-127(14)(a)(I)(A)
  Level II Alcohol Education: proof of enrollment or alcohol certification for reinstatement required
   Alcohol Therapy
 
 
 
not required unless prior alcohol related conviction
No Prior Conviction or Revocation:
refer to grids for level of alcohol education
alcohol certification for reinstatement
Prior Conviction or Revocation:
68 Hours in not less than 8 months
proof of enrollment

If the total period of license restraint under this subparagraph (II) is not sufficient to allow for the completion of level II alcohol and drug education and treatment, or the documentation of completion of such education and treatment is incomplete at the time of reinstatement, proof of current enrollment in a level II alcohol and drug education and treatment program certified by the division of alcohol and drug abuse pursuant to CRS 42-4-1301.3, on a form approved by the department, shall be filed with the department.  CRS 42-2-126(7)(c)(III), CRS 42-2-132(2)(a)(II)(C)

  Reinstatement - Second or Subsequent Revocation - BAC Refusal   refer to link Continuing License Loss Until Reinstatement  
1.  Application for reinstatement: by mail only to DMV Driver Control Section - Reinstatement  - not allowed at any DMV Office
2.  Written and driving tests:  mandatory.  CRS 42-2-126(7)(c)(I), CRS 42-2-111, DOR Regulation 1 CCR 204-6
3.  Mandatory interlock restricted license:  2 years - refer to persistent drunk driver   CRS 42-2-132.5(1.7)
4.  Insurance Requirement - BAC Refusal - Second or Subsequent Revocation

Type of Insurance. 

Mandatory SR-22 Insurance 

Period Required. 

3 years
Authority.  CRS 42-7-408(1)(b)
5.  Education required for reinstatement  
    
CRS 42-2-126(7)(c)(II), CRS 42-2-127(14)(a)(I)(A), CRS 42-2-132(2)(a)(II)(B), persistent drunk driver CRS 42-2-132.5(1.7)
  Level II Alcohol Education proof of enrollment or completion certificate required
   Alcohol Therapy
 
proof of enrollment or completion certificate required
Prior Conviction or Revocation: 68 Hours in not less than 8 months

If the total period of license restraint under this subparagraph (II) is not sufficient to allow for the completion of level II alcohol and drug education and treatment, or the documentation of completion of such education and treatment is incomplete at the time of reinstatement, proof of current enrollment in a level II alcohol and drug education and treatment program certified by the division of alcohol and drug abuse pursuant to CRS 42-4-1301.3, on a form approved by the department, shall be filed with the department.  CRS 42-2-126(7)(c)(III), CRS 42-2-132(2)(a)(II)(C)

  DMV Forms Application for Reinstatement Affidavit of Enrollment - Alcohol Education or Therapy
    Alcohol Certification for Reinstatement